An Alternative to Immediate Prostate Biopsy

The following article dated August 6th came from a site entitled Prostatesnatchers authored by a noted prostate oncologist, Dr. Mark Scholz. He suggests that a commercial OPKO-4Kscore blood test and a high-resolution color Doppler ultrasound or a 3-Tesla multi-parametric MRI can help identify aggressive cancers and minimize the use of standard 12-core prostate biopsies and their potential side effects. The OPKO-4Kscore blood test is comprised of measurements of total and free PSA coupled with proprietary tests for intact PSA and a panel of four kallikrein (a specific group of enzymes) blood markers.  My own prostate oncologist commented favorably on this test. “It won’t be the last word, but it is a productive departure from single-lab-value (PSA) technology, which is over 30 years old.”  Remember the contents of this website are not intended as personal recommendations but the potential use of this information should be discussed with your personal physician. You should also check on the cost and insurance coverage of the tests described below.

“You PSA is elevated. Now your doctor recommends a needle biopsy, 12 cores through the rectum to check for cancer in the prostate.  Sounds icky, but also logical; after all who wants to miss cancer? But come on, do you really have to do 12 stabs via the rectum?

Each year over a million men submit their prostates for a biopsy.  At an average cost of around four thousand dollars, the prostate biopsy business is a 4-billion-dollar-a-year enterprise.  But it’s not merely the cost that gives pause.  Three percent of men end up hospitalized with life-threatening infections.  Around a 100,000 men every year get a confounding diagnosis of Grade 6 prostate cancer, a truly harmless entity, unless you get suckered into an unnecessary radical prostatectomy.

Obviously, prostate biopsy is an unpleasant proposition with notable risks.  However, ignoring a high PSA incurs the risk of missing a diagnosis of a higher grade prostate cancer. As things stand now, of the million biopsies being done annually, over a hundred thousand men with Grade 7 or higher cancers are being detected. For these men, their early diagnosis is beneficial, leading to early, curative treatment in a timely fashion.

How can we detect the 100,000 men with higher-grade cancers that need to be detected without doing 900,000 “unnecessary” biopsies?   The answer to this question continues to evolve as technology marches forward. Our latest thinking at Prostate Oncology (assuming the PSA is not wildly elevated, say over 20) is a three step process:

1.    Simply repeat the PSA to confirm it is indeed abnormally elevated.  All sorts of things can cause temporary elevations of PSA ranging from nonspecific inflammation of the prostate, to recent sexual activity, to simple laboratory errors. 

2.    If the PSA remains elevated with repeat testing the next step to consider is an OPKO-4Kscore blood test. The OPKO test reports a percentage estimate of the likelihood of higher grade cancer being present.  The test is not perfect, but it performs pretty well.  For example, if a specific patient receives an OPKO report with an estimated risk of high grade disease of less than 15%, a standard random biopsy (if he elected to do one) will confirm the absence of high grade disease 92% of the time. Not bad.

3.    Our next step at Prostate Oncology in the cases where a patient has an OPKO test indicating that the risk of high grade disease is over 15%, is to obtain a prostate scan with high-resolution color Doppler ultrasound or with a 3-Tesla multiparametric MRI. With scanning, the location of the high-grade disease can be determined over 90% of the time so that a targeted biopsy with 2 or 3 cores can be substituted for the traditional 12-core biopsy.       

The business of prostate biopsy has become so out of control the US Preventative Services Task Force advocates against PSA testing altogether.  The Task Force’s scientifically-based arguments that PSA testing is causing more harm than good are really quite convincing.  However, back in 2011 when they published their recommendations, the OPKO test and 3-Tesla multiparametric prostate MRI were unavailable. With the advent of these new technologies, PSA screening to detect higher grade prostate cancers at an early stage when they are still curable makes perfect sense.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *